Never Buy a Franchise Without Talking to an Outside Consultant First

Franchising

Never Buy a Franchise Without Talking to an Outside Consultant First

The franchisor has a sales team. The franchise broker works for the franchisor. The FDD is 300 pages of legal language designed to protect the brand. Who is working for you?

S
Sarah Moudry
••7 min read
Never Buy a Franchise Without Talking to an Outside Consultant First

Let me tell you exactly what happens when you start exploring a franchise opportunity without an outside advocate.

You fill out an inquiry form on the franchisor's website. Within 24 hours, a franchise development representative calls you. They are friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely enthusiastic about the brand. They send you a glossy overview. They invite you to a webinar. They introduce you to their "validation team" — a curated list of franchisees who are happy to talk.

Every person you speak with in this process works for the franchisor or is paid by the franchisor. Every piece of information you receive has been reviewed by the franchisor's legal and marketing teams. Every franchisee you are connected with has been selected because they will say positive things.

This is not a conspiracy. It is a sales process. And it is a very good one.

The problem is that you are making a $100,000 to $500,000 decision — one that will define the next ten years of your life — inside a sales funnel designed by the people who profit from your signature.

You need someone in your corner.

What an Outside Consultant Actually Does

An outside franchise consultant — one who is not paid by the franchisor, not affiliated with a franchise brokerage network, and not earning a referral fee from the brand you are evaluating — does something none of the other people in this process will do.

They tell you the things the franchisor does not want you to know.

They read the FDD with your interests in mind, not the brand's. They know which Item 19 disclosures are misleading and which are honest. They know how to calculate the real total cost of entry — not the franchise fee, but the full investment including working capital, ramp-up losses, and the royalty obligation over the life of the agreement.

They talk to franchisees the franchisor did not put on the validation list. The ones who are struggling. The ones who are in litigation. The ones who wish they had never signed.

They compare the brand you are considering against alternatives in the same category — including the option of building independently — and give you an honest assessment of which path makes the most sense for your specific situation, capital, skills, and market.

They negotiate on your behalf. Franchise agreements are presented as non-negotiable. They are not. An experienced consultant knows what is movable and what is not, and they push for terms that protect you.

The Franchise Broker Is Not Your Advocate

This is the most important thing to understand before you start the franchise buying process.

A franchise broker — also called a franchise consultant in many brokerage networks — is not working for you. They are paid by the franchisor. When you sign a franchise agreement with a brand in their portfolio, the franchisor pays the broker a referral fee, typically 40 to 50 percent of the franchise fee.

That means a broker steering you toward a $50,000 franchise fee brand earns $20,000 to $25,000 when you sign. A broker steering you toward a $100,000 franchise fee brand earns $40,000 to $50,000.

The broker has a direct financial incentive to match you with a brand that pays a high referral fee, regardless of whether it is the best fit for your goals, your market, or your financial situation.

Most franchise brokers are good people who genuinely try to make good matches. But the structure of their compensation creates a conflict of interest that no amount of good intentions can fully eliminate.

An outside consultant who charges you a flat fee or hourly rate — and earns nothing from the franchisor — has no such conflict. Their only incentive is to give you the best possible advice.

What the FDD Is Not Telling You

The Franchise Disclosure Document is a legal requirement. Franchisors must provide it at least 14 days before you sign. It contains 23 items covering everything from the franchisor's litigation history to the financial performance of existing units.

It is also 200 to 400 pages of legal language written by the franchisor's attorneys to protect the franchisor's interests.

Here is what most franchise buyers do not understand about the FDD:

Item 19 is optional and selective. Franchisors are not required to disclose financial performance data. When they do, they choose what to include. A brand might show average gross revenue for the top quartile of performers while burying the median in a footnote. An outside consultant knows how to read these disclosures and what questions to ask when the data looks too good.

Item 20 tells you about turnover. The number of franchisees who left the system — voluntarily or involuntarily — in the past three years is disclosed in Item 20. High turnover is a red flag. An outside consultant knows what normal looks like and what should concern you.

Item 21 shows the franchisor's financial health. If the franchisor is losing money, carrying significant debt, or has thin cash reserves, that affects your investment. An outside consultant reads these financials and tells you what they mean.

The agreement is not the FDD. The FDD is a disclosure document. The franchise agreement is the contract you sign. They are different documents, and the agreement often contains terms that are more restrictive than the FDD suggests. An outside consultant reviews both.

The Validation Call Trap

Every franchise sales process includes a validation phase — a period where you are encouraged to call existing franchisees and ask them about their experience.

This sounds like due diligence. It is not, if you are only calling the franchisees the franchisor gave you.

The validation list is curated. The franchisees on it have agreed to take calls. They are typically the brand's most successful and most enthusiastic operators. They are not representative of the average franchisee experience.

An outside consultant knows how to find franchisees who are not on the validation list. They know how to search Item 20 of the FDD for franchisees who left the system and contact them directly. They know what questions to ask to get past the polished answers and into the real experience.

"Would you do it again?" is a different question than "How is business?" The answers are often very different.

The Questions Nobody Asks Before Signing

Here are the questions that most franchise buyers never ask — and that an outside consultant will make sure you do:

What is the median net income of a franchisee in this system, after royalties, marketing fees, and debt service? Not the average. Not the top quartile. The median.

What percentage of franchisees in this system have renewed their agreement at the end of their first term? Renewal rates tell you whether franchisees believe the investment was worth it.

What are the most common reasons franchisees have left this system in the past three years? Item 20 gives you the numbers. An outside consultant helps you find out the reasons.

What does the franchisor's support actually look like after the first year? The grand opening support is always excellent. The ongoing support is where most franchise systems fall short.

What happens to your investment if the franchisor is acquired, goes bankrupt, or decides to change the system in ways that require significant capital investment from franchisees?

If you cannot answer these questions before you sign, you are not ready to sign.

What We Believe at BIZLINXAI

We are the buyer's advocate. We believe that no one should sign a franchise agreement without independent counsel — someone who is paid by the buyer, not the brand.

The franchise industry has spent decades building a sales infrastructure that is extraordinarily effective at moving buyers from inquiry to signature. That infrastructure is not designed to protect you. It is designed to close deals.

You deserve better than that. You deserve someone who will read the FDD with your interests in mind, talk to the franchisees the brand did not introduce you to, run the real numbers on the royalty obligation, and tell you honestly whether this is the right investment for your specific situation.

That is what an outside consultant does. That is what we do.

Never buy a franchise without one.

Found this useful? Share it with your network.

Share

Explore Topics

#franchising#franchise buyer#due diligence#franchise consultant#buyer advocacy
S

Written by

Sarah Moudry

Content creator and writer sharing insights and stories.

Found this useful? Share it.

Share